Changed F3 Exam Questions

CIMA F3 links the cost of debt to the tax shield created by the tax deductibility of interest. The effective cost of servicing debt to a company is therefore the post-tax cost of debt, commonly expressed as kd(1−T)k_d(1-T)kd​(1−T). This makes statement C correct: when evaluating financing decisions and WACC, the company benefits from interest tax relief, so the relevant servicing cost is after tax. Statement A is also treated as correct in the standard F3 exam context: zero-coupon debt pays no periodic coupon interest, so there are no regular interest payments generating the conventional annual tax-deductible interest expense and therefore the familiar tax-shield effect on “interest payments” is not obtained in the same way (i.e., the typical coupon-based shield is eliminated). Statement B is incorrect because the size of the tax shield depends on the tax rate; if corporation tax changes, the value of the tax relief changes. Statement D is incorrect because if corporation tax rates rise, the tax shield from deductible interest would increase, not reduce (a higher tax rate increases the tax saving per dollar of interest). Hence the two correct statements are A and C.

Reasoning:

A share exchange allows Company B’s shareholders to stay invested and participate in the future gains (synergies, growth) of the combined business.

A is wrong: cash offers are what “realise” an investment and crystallise a capital gain.

B is wrong: a share exchange introduces foreign currency exposure (to A$), whereas a cash offer in B$ does not.

C is wrong: Company B is in the older, more established market, so it is more likely that market is efficient, not Company A’s.

So D is the correct explanation.

Target earnings after tax for 20X2:

8.0m×1.05=8.4m8.0 \text{m} \times 1.05 = 8.4 \text{m}8.0m×1.05=8.4m

Interest on the new bond:

1.0m×4%=0.04m1.0 \text{m} \times 4\% = 0.04 \text{m}1.0m×4%=0.04m

Let required operating profit (PBIT) = XXX.

Profit before tax = X−0.04X - 0.04X−0.04.

Tax at 20% → profit after tax:

Earnings=(X−0.04)×0.8\text{Earnings} = (X - 0.04)\times 0.8Earnings=(X−0.04)×0.8

Set equal to the target 8.4m:

(X−0.04)×0.8=8.4⇒X−0.04=8.40.8=10.5⇒X=10.5+0.04=10.54m(X - 0.04)\times 0.8 = 8.4 \Rightarrow X - 0.04 = \frac{8.4}{0.8} = 10.5 \Rightarrow X = 10.5 + 0.04 = 10.54 \text{m}(X−0.04)×0.8=8.4⇒X−0.04=0.88.4​=10.5⇒X=10.5+0.04=10.54m

So minimum operating profit = $10.54 million.