ISO 9001 ISO-9001-Lead-Auditor Book

Relevant ISO 9001 Requirement

Clause 7.3 – Awareness states that persons doing work under the organisation’s control shall be aware of:

The quality policy;

Relevant quality objectives;

Their contribution to the effectiveness of the QMS;

The implications of not conforming with QMS requirements.

A critical point is that ISO 9001 uses the phrase:

“persons doing work under the organisation ' s control”

This includes:

Employees,

Temporary personnel,

Agency personnel,

Subcontractors performing work on behalf of the organisation.

Why Option B is Correct

In the scenario:

The refrigeration engineers performing the actual maintenance and repair services are all subcontractors.

The Managing Director states that these subcontractors have not been informed of:

the Quality Policy,

quality objectives,

plans to address risks and opportunities.

The justification given is that the subcontractors themselves have ISO 9001-certified management systems.

However, ISO 9001 certification of a subcontractor does not remove the organisation ' s responsibility to ensure persons working under its control are aware of the organisation ' s own QMS requirements.

Therefore, the organisation has failed to demonstrate compliance with Clause 7.3 Awareness .

Why the Other Options Are Incorrect

A. Clause 7.4 – Communication

The scenario does not primarily indicate a failure of communication processes.

The issue is not whether communication methods exist, but whether the subcontractors have the required awareness.

C. Clause 7.2 – Competence

The Managing Director explicitly states that competence requirements are applied to both full-time staff and subcontractors.

No evidence is presented that competence has not been determined or evaluated.

Therefore, a competence failure is not the strongest conclusion.

D. Clause 7.5 – Documented Information

The scenario indicates documented information exists and was reviewed by the auditor.

No evidence suggests documented information is missing, uncontrolled, or unavailable.

Therefore, Clause 7.5 is not the most likely issue.

ISO-Aligned Conclusion

The organisation relies entirely on subcontracted refrigeration engineers to deliver its certified services. Because these personnel perform work under the organisation ' s control, ISO 9001 requires them to be aware of the organisation ' s quality policy, objectives, and relevant QMS requirements.

The evidence shows this awareness has not been established.

Answer: B. 7.3 Awareness

===========

Comprehensive and Detailed In-Depth Explanation:

Completeness ensures that all necessary audit evidence, observations, and findings are properly documented, which is critical for traceability and accountability in an audit.

While transparency and fair presentation are principles of auditing, completeness is specifically related to maintaining audit work documents, as required in ISO 19011:2018, Clause 6.5.4 (Preparing Audit Work Documents).

According to the ISO 9000:2015 - Quality management systems — Fundamentals and vocabulary, correction is defined as “action to eliminate a detected nonconformity”. A nonconformity is defined as “non-fulfilment of a requirement”. Therefore, the process of modifying a non-conforming product to bring it within acceptance criteria is a correction, as it eliminates the non-fulfilment of the product specification. The other options are not correct, as they have different definitions and purposes:

•Concession: permission to release or use a nonconforming product, service or process

•Corrective action: action to eliminate the cause of a nonconformity and to prevent recurrence

•Preventive action: action to eliminate the cause of a potential nonconformity or other undesirable potential situation

An auditor undertaking their first third-party audit is normally treated as an auditor under supervision. They may participate in audit activities, but should be monitored and supported by the audit team leader.

They should therefore review their auditing performance with the audit team leader and conduct interviews only with the audit team leader present.

They should not lead the closing meeting, independently interview auditees, or decide nonconformity grading alone. ISO 9001:2015 requires audits to be conducted objectively and by competent auditors, and ISO 9001 refers to ISO 19011 for audit guidance.