ISO-9001-Lead-Auditor Exam Dumps : QMS ISO 9001:2015 Lead Auditor Exam

Comprehensive and Detailed In-Depth Explanation:

Audit risks are categorized into different types based on where failures may occur in the QMS audit process.

Clause References:

ISO 19011:2018, Clause 6.3 – Managing Audit Risk: Defines different audit risks, including control risk.

Why is the Correct Answer A?

Control risk occurs when internal controls fail to prevent or detect nonconformities.

Even if controls exist, the risk remains if the QMS fails to identify or correct defects.

Why are the Other Options Incorrect?

B (Inherent risk) → This refers to risks naturally present in processes, even before controls are applied.

C (Detection risk) → This is the risk that an auditor fails to detect nonconformities.

D (Operational risk) → This refers to risks related to day-to-day business operations, not QMS audits.

The nonconformity was raised against ISO 9001:2015 Clause 8.5.1 – Control of production and service provision. This clause requires organisations to carry out production and service provision under controlled conditions, including:

the use of suitable infrastructure and equipment,

the availability and use of appropriate monitoring and control, and

the prevention of nonconforming outputs being delivered to customers.

In this scenario, the evidence shows a systemic failure in operational control, not isolated human error.

Explanation of the selected evidence:

E. The organisation failed to control the laundry operations in 5 shops adequately.

Clause 8.5.1 requires consistent control of service provision. The fact that 80% of complaints come from five specific shops demonstrates a lack of effective operational control in those locations.

G. The organisation failed to maintain all of its equipment to an adequate standard.

Clause 8.5.1 requires suitable infrastructure for service provision. Management acknowledged that equipment in these shops is old and cannot currently be replaced, meaning it is not being maintained at a level necessary to ensure conformity of service.

H. Some equipment used was not suitable for the laundry process.

The poor cleaning outcomes and high complaint levels directly indicate that the equipment is not fit for purpose, which is a clear breach of the requirement to provide suitable resources for controlled service provision under Clause 8.5.1.

Explanation of why the other options are not appropriate evidence for Clause 8.5.1:

A relates to strategic planning and investment decisions, not directly to operational control.

B and C relate to inspection activities, which were not evidenced in the scenario.

D and F relate to complaint handling behaviour, which would align more closely with Clause 9.1.2 (customer satisfaction) or Clause 10.2 (nonconformity and corrective action), not Clause 8.5.1.

ISO-aligned conclusion:

The nonconformity is justified because the organisation is continuing to provide services using unsuitable and inadequately maintained equipment, resulting in repeated service failures in multiple locations. This demonstrates a clear failure to control service provision as required by ISO 9001:2015 Clause 8.5.1, supported by evidence E, G and H.

ISO 9001:2015 requires audits to be planned and conducted to ensure the quality management system conforms to requirements and is effectively implemented. While ISO 9001 sets the requirement, it explicitly refers auditors to ISO 19011 for detailed guidance on audit planning and execution.

ISO 9001:2015, Clause 9.2.2 (NOTE) states that guidance for auditing management systems is provided in ISO 19011 .

Based on ISO 19011:2018 (Clause 6.3 – Initiating and preparing for the audit), the audit team leader is responsible for finalising key planning issues before documenting the audit plan, especially for multi-site and multi-country audits.

Explanation of the selected options:

A. Arrangement of translation of the audit report

ISO 19011 requires consideration of communication and language arrangements during audit preparation. Where sites are located in different countries, potential language difficulties must be addressed during planning, including translation needs for reports and communications.

C. Structuring the audit plan to account for audit trails

ISO 19011 requires audits to follow audit trails across processes, functions, and interfaces. The audit plan must be structured to allow logical progression through interrelated processes, which must be decided before the plan is documented.

D. Determining available IT infrastructure for remote participation

ISO 19011 allows the use of remote auditing techniques. When audit team members are located in different countries, the audit team leader must confirm the availability of IT infrastructure to support remote participation in opening and closing meetings as part of audit planning.

E. Considering processes not operating at the time of the audit

ISO 19011 requires the audit team leader to consider process availability. If some processes are not operating during the audit period, alternative audit methods (such as records review or rescheduling) must be planned in advance and reflected in the audit plan.

Explanation of why the other options are not selected:

B: ISO 19011 requires identification of roles and functions to be audited, not specific names, at the audit planning stage.

F: Moderation or grading of nonconformities is performed after audit findings are raised, not during audit planning.

G: Post-audit communication arrangements are addressed during reporting and follow-up activities, not before documenting the audit plan.

H: Follow-up audits are planned only if required after audit results are known, not during initial audit planning.