CIMA F3 Exam With Confidence Using Practice Dumps

Answer: D. Discounted cash flow analysis based on forecast future free cash flows.

Because the company is unlisted, growing faster than the industry, and pays only a fixed dividend (not linked to performance), dividend or simple P/E methods won’t capture its value properly. A DCF based on future free cash flows is most suitable.

Target earnings after tax for 20X2:

8.0m×1.05=8.4m8.0 \text{m} \times 1.05 = 8.4 \text{m}8.0m×1.05=8.4m

Interest on the new bond:

1.0m×4%=0.04m1.0 \text{m} \times 4\% = 0.04 \text{m}1.0m×4%=0.04m

Let required operating profit (PBIT) = XXX.

Profit before tax = X−0.04X - 0.04X−0.04.

Tax at 20% → profit after tax:

Earnings=(X−0.04)×0.8\text{Earnings} = (X - 0.04)\times 0.8Earnings=(X−0.04)×0.8

Set equal to the target 8.4m:

(X−0.04)×0.8=8.4⇒X−0.04=8.40.8=10.5⇒X=10.5+0.04=10.54m(X - 0.04)\times 0.8 = 8.4 \Rightarrow X - 0.04 = \frac{8.4}{0.8} = 10.5 \Rightarrow X = 10.5 + 0.04 = 10.54 \text{m}(X−0.04)×0.8=8.4⇒X−0.04=0.88.4​=10.5⇒X=10.5+0.04=10.54m

So minimum operating profit = $10.54 million.

The assistant has discounted free cash flows to all investors at the WACC (10%). That gives the value of the business (enterprise value), not directly the value of equity.

For a geared company:

If you discount free cash flows to the firm (all investors) at the WACC, you obtain the total value of the firm (V).

To get equity value (E), you must then subtract the market value of debt (D):

E=V−DE = V - DE=V−D

Here, the company has a $6m 7% undated bond trading at par, so the market value of debt is $6m. That amount has not been deducted.

The other options are not errors:

The perpetuity discounting using 7.91.102×0.10\frac{7.9}{1.10^2 \times 0.10}1.102×0.107.9​ is correct for a constant cash flow from year 3 onward.

Using WACC (10%) is appropriate for FCFF.

Tax at 20% is already reflected in either the cash flows or the WACC; it is not “missing” as a separate line.

So the specific mistake is failing to deduct the $6m debt value, i.e. option D.