SAVE International VMA Actual Questions

The Value Methodology (VM) Job Plan, as outlined in the VMF 1 course and SAVE International’s Value Methodology Standard, consists of six phases: Information, Function Analysis, Creative, Evaluation, Development, and Presentation. This was established in Question 1, where the VM Job Plan was confirmed to have six phases. The last four phases, therefore, are: Creative, Evaluation, Development, and Presentation. However, the options include “Implementation,” which is not a formal phase in the standard VM Job Plan but is often considered a post-study activity (e.g., in the post-study phase, where recommendations are implemented). For the purposes of the VMA exam, which focuses on the VMF 1 curriculum, Implementation is sometimes treated as an extension of the Presentation Phase, where the team ensures stakeholder buy-in and facilitates the transition to implementation.

Thus, the correct sequence of the last four phases, interpreting Implementation as the post-Presentation activity, is:

Creative(third phase, but the first of the last four).

Evaluation(fourth phase): Assess ideas for feasibility and value improvement.

Development(fifth phase): Refine selected ideas into actionable proposals.

Presentation(sixth phase): Present recommendations to stakeholders for approval and implementation.

Implementation: Follows Presentation as a post-study activity to execute the recommendations.

Option A (Development, Presentation, Evaluation, and Implementation) is incorrect because Evaluation must precede Development—ideas are evaluated before being developed into proposals.

Option B (Evaluation, Development, Presentation, and Implementation) is correct, as it follows the VM Job Plan’s sequence and includes Implementation as the post-study step.

Option C (Evaluation, Development, Implementation, and Presentation) is incorrect because Presentation (delivering recommendations) must occur before Implementation.

Option D (Development, Evaluation, Presentation, and Implementation) is incorrect because Development cannot precede Evaluation in the VM Job Plan.

Function Analysis in Value Methodology involves identifying and classifying functions using verb-noun combinations, as taught in the VMF 1 course (Core Competency #2). The basic function of an item is its primary purpose—what it must do to fulfill its intended use. According to SAVE International’s Value Methodology Standard, “functions should be defined in broad, measurable terms (verb-noun format) to capture the core purpose.” For a pen or pencil, the basic function is the most fundamental action it performs. A pen or pencil mustmark surface, as this captures the essential action of leaving a visible trace (e.g., ink or graphite) on a surface (e.g., paper), which is the core purpose of both tools, regardless of their specific use (writing, drawing, etc.).

Option A (Write documents) is incorrect because writing documents is a specific application, not the basic function; a pen can also draw or mark without writing a document.

Option B (Color surface) is incorrect because coloring implies adding color, which is not the primary function of a standard pen or pencil (e.g., a pencil typically uses graphite, not color).

Option C (Mark surface) is correct, as it defines the basic function of a pen or pencil in the broadest, most fundamental terms, encompassing all uses (writing, drawing, marking).

Option D (Convey message) is incorrect because conveying a message is a higher-level outcome, not the basic function; a pen can mark a surface without conveying a message (e.g., a random scribble).

In Value Methodology’s Function Analysis, functions and activities are distinct concepts, as taught in the VMF 1 course (Core Competency #2: Function Analysis). According to SAVE International’s Value Methodology Standard, “functions are what a product, process, or system does, expressed in a verb-noun format (e.g., ‘restrict access’), while activities are tasks, actions, or operations that describe how a function is performed (e.g., ‘install screws’)” (as noted in Question 43). The question asks for the option that does not contain activities, meaning it should only include functions (verb-noun combinations) and no activities (specific tasks).

For a residential door:

Option A (Restrict access, improve safety, transmit force):

Restrict access (function: the door limits entry).

Improve safety (function: the door enhances security).

Transmit force (function: the handle or hinges transfer force to open/close).All are functions in verb-noun format, with no activities (specific tasks).

Option B (Connect spaces, construct frame, attract user):

Connect spaces (function: the door links rooms).

Construct frame (activity: the task of building the frame).

Attract user (function: the door’s aesthetics draw attention).Contains an activity (construct frame).

Option C (Rotate door, support load, grasp handle):

Rotate door (function: the hinges enable rotation).

Support load (function: the frame bears the door’s weight).

Grasp handle (activity: the action of holding the handle).Contains an activity (grasp handle).

Option D (Install screws, separate spaces, secure space):

Install screws (activity: the task of fastening screws).

Separate spaces (function: the door divides rooms).

Secure space (function: the lock protects the area).Contains an activity (install screws).

Option A (Restrict access, improve safety, transmit force) is correct, as it contains only functions, with no activities.

Option B is incorrect because “construct frame” is an activity.

Option C is incorrect because “grasp handle” is an activity.

Option D is incorrect because “install screws” is an activity.

The Function Analysis System Technique (FAST) diagram is a key tool in Value Methodology’s Function Analysis phase, as taught in the VMF 1 course (Core Competency #2). FAST diagrams map the relationships between functions, with the horizontal axis showing the “how-why” logic (critical path) and vertical lines called scope lines defining the study’s boundaries. According to SAVE International’s Value Methodology Standard, “the left vertical line in a FAST diagram is a scope line, and the function immediately to its right is typically the higher-order function, which represents the overarching goal or need for the system.” The functionto the leftof the left scope line is outside the study’s scope and often represents an even broader objective or external assumption that drives the higher-order function. However, in standard FAST diagramming, thehigher-order functionis the closest function to the left scope line within the scope, and functions to the left of the scope line (e.g., P in the diagram from Question 30) are external.

In the context of the VMA exam and VMF 1, the question likely tests the understanding of the higher-order function’s position relative to the scope line. As established in Question 18, Function E (just inside the left scope line B) is the higher-order function. Functions to the left of the left scope line (e.g., P) are typically external assumptions or broader objectives, but the options provided (A, B, C, D) refer to standard function classifications within the FAST framework. Thehigher-order function(C) is the most relevant choice, as it is the function closest to the left scope line within the study’s scope, and the question may be interpreted as asking for the function type associated with that position.

Option A (Basic Function) is incorrect because the basic function is typically more central on the critical path, not at the far left.

Option B (Secondary Function) is incorrect because secondary functions are vertical (supporting the critical path), not on the main path near the left scope line.

Option C (Higher Order Function) is correct, as the higher-order function is located just to the right of the left scope line (e.g., Function E), and the question may be interpreted in this context based on standard FAST conventions.

Option D (Lower Order Function) is incorrect because lower-order functions are to the right of the basic function, representing more specific outcomes, not near the left scope line.