The original Value Methodology (VM) Job Plan, developed by Lawrence D. Miles in the 1940s, was rooted in a problem-solving approach inspired by the scientific method. As outlined in the VMF 1 course (Core Competency #1: Value Methodology Overview), Miles adapted a systematic problem-solving framework to create the VM Job Plan, which later evolved into the six-phase process used today (Information, Function Analysis, Creative, Evaluation, Development, Presentation). The original problem-solving approach, as described in SAVE International’s historical documentation of VM, follows the scientific method’s four steps: Observation, Hypothesis, Experimentation, and Conclusion.
Observation: Observe the problem or system (e.g., high costs, inefficiencies) to understand the current state, aligning with the Information Phase.
Hypothesis: Form a hypothesis about how to improve value (e.g., identifying key functions or alternatives), similar to Function Analysis and Creative Phases.
Experimentation: Test the hypothesis by developing and evaluating alternatives, akin to the Evaluation and Development Phases.
Conclusion: Draw conclusions and implement solutions, corresponding to the Presentation Phase.
This order—Observation, Hypothesis, Experimentation, Conclusion—is the standard sequence of the scientific method, which Miles used as the foundation for VM’s systematic approach to problem-solving.
Option A (Hypothesis, Observation, Experimentation, Conclusion) is incorrect because observation must come first to identify the problem.
Option B (Observation, Experimentation, Hypothesis, Conclusion) is incorrect because hypothesizing should precede experimentation.
Option C (Hypothesis, Experimentation, Observation, Conclusion) is incorrect because observation must come before forming a hypothesis.
Option D (Observation, Hypothesis, Experimentation, Conclusion) is correct, as it matches the scientific method’s order, which underpins the original VM Job Plan.
[:, SAVE International, “Value Methodology Standard and Body of Knowledge,” available athttps://www.value-eng.org, historical section on the origins of VM and its problem-solving roots., SAVE International, VMF 1 Core Competency #1 (Value Methodology Overview), detailing the history of the VM Job Plan and its basis in the scientific method., ]