In the Assessment and Testing core area, CACREP requires that counselors understand:
The use of diagnostic classification systems (such as DSM),
The difference between identity or behavior and a mental disorder, and
The central role of distress or impairment in making a diagnosis.
For gender dysphoria, diagnostic criteria emphasize that:
A person may experience incongruence between their experienced/expressed gender and assigned sex,
However, this incongruence alone is not sufficient for a mental health diagnosis,
A diagnosis is appropriate only when the experience is associated with clinically significant distress or impairment in social, occupational, or other important areas of functioning.
Evaluating the options:
A. Considering surgical reassignment – Not required for diagnosis. Many individuals with gender dysphoria may never seek surgery.
B. Strong dislike for their anatomy – This can be one feature, but by itself does not justify a diagnosis without associated distress or impairment.
C. Desire for secondary sexual characteristics of another gender – Again, this can be part of the experience but is not sufficient alone to meet diagnostic criteria.
D. There was clinically significant distress. – This is the essential condition across DSM diagnoses: the symptoms must cause clinically significant distress or impairment. Without that, a formal diagnosis of gender dysphoria should not be made.
Therefore, the counselor would only diagnose gender dysphoria if D (there was clinically significant distress) is present.